Page 1 of 1

Used FRH as a hand-warmer?

Posted: Sun Nov 30, 2014 2:38 am
by IndyRacingNut
Do the FRH's lose ALL heat-emitting properties after a one-time use from cooking an entree, or are they (in sufficient quantity) reusable as hand-warmers later on, so long as you have enough of them?

Re: Used FRH as a hand-warmer?

Posted: Sun Nov 30, 2014 1:27 pm
by RockyRaab
They work a second time just as well as matches.

Re: Used FRH as a hand-warmer?

Posted: Mon Dec 01, 2014 12:43 am
by noderaser
They work by a chemical reaction, once the primary chemical is used up there's no more heat.

Re: Used FRH as a hand-warmer?

Posted: Sat Feb 07, 2015 8:21 pm
by chitoryu12
The FRH expends itself when activated, and I don't know of any way to even temporarily shut down the reaction. It could potentially be used as a hand warmer if you waited for it to cool down (which can take a while if you're not wrapping it in something to help insulate the heat), but you'd be restricted to whatever heat was left.

Re: Used FRH as a hand-warmer?

Posted: Sun Jan 15, 2017 2:39 am
by magu2k
It's pretty much been said. However, there is a possibility here. While it's true, once the reaction finishes its' done. But it's an oxidation reaction.
If you put it in a glove or similar quick enough and can do so without burning yourself (which is the hard part here!) it could work while it is still reacting, as it needs oxygen to keep going. They are largely identical to the handwarmer packs, they don't burn you though, because they do not have enough oxygen so it's a much slower reaction. If you want to try it, GO FOR IT! lemme know how it is.... but I suspect once it is going full .... stream... you are probably not gonna have a lot of luck.

Re: Used FRH as a hand-warmer?

Posted: Sun Jan 15, 2017 9:18 am
by Eistee
magu2k wrote:It's pretty much been said. However, there is a possibility here. While it's true, once the reaction finishes its' done. But it's an oxidation reaction.
If you put it in a glove or similar quick enough and can do so without burning yourself (which is the hard part here!) it could work while it is still reacting, as it needs oxygen to keep going. They are largely identical to the handwarmer packs, they don't burn you though, because they do not have enough oxygen so it's a much slower reaction. If you want to try it, GO FOR IT! lemme know how it is.... but I suspect once it is going full .... stream... you are probably not gonna have a lot of luck.
They do not need oxygen out of the air for the reaction, they take it out of the Water, thats why hydrogen gas is produced in the reaction

Re: Used FRH as a hand-warmer?

Posted: Tue Jan 17, 2017 8:05 pm
by Drew78
Eistee wrote:
magu2k wrote:It's pretty much been said. However, there is a possibility here. While it's true, once the reaction finishes its' done. But it's an oxidation reaction.
If you put it in a glove or similar quick enough and can do so without burning yourself (which is the hard part here!) it could work while it is still reacting, as it needs oxygen to keep going. They are largely identical to the handwarmer packs, they don't burn you though, because they do not have enough oxygen so it's a much slower reaction. If you want to try it, GO FOR IT! lemme know how it is.... but I suspect once it is going full .... stream... you are probably not gonna have a lot of luck.
They do not need oxygen out of the air for the reaction, they take it out of the Water, thats why hydrogen gas is produced in the reaction
Eistee hitting us with a bit of his Chemistry background..lol

Re: Used FRH as a hand-warmer?

Posted: Tue Jan 17, 2017 8:51 pm
by Westview
They will work again for a second time, but it's not really a good idea because they won't be nearly as hot and will only be warm for probably a few minutes. Also, the palm of your hands would be covered in a solution of water; salt; iron; and magnesium.

Re: Used FRH as a hand-warmer?

Posted: Wed Jan 25, 2017 12:20 am
by Landbigtuna
After cooking an MRE meal, I used them while squid fishing this season and stuck it into an outer coat pocket. It kept warm for quite a while.